If you buy steel plate, beams, channels, angles, or fabricated steel assemblies, welding is where material quality becomes real project performance. The four most common arc-welding processes used across structural steel, heavy plate, equipment frames, and industrial fabrication are:
- GMAW (Gas Metal Arc Welding) — commonly called MIG welding
- SMAW (Shielded Metal Arc Welding) — commonly called Stick welding
- FCAW (Flux-Cored Arc Welding) — self-shielded or gas-shielded
- SAW (Submerged Arc Welding) — high-productivity welding under granular flux
1) Welding Process Basics (Why These Four Dominate Steel)
All four processes create an electric arc that melts base metal and filler metal to form a joint. The big differences are how filler metal is delivered and how the molten weld pool is protected from oxygen/nitrogen/hydrogen in the air (which can cause porosity, cracking, or poor weld properties).
That protection comes from:
- External shielding gas (GMAW, FCAW-G / “dual-shield”)
- Flux coating on the electrode (SMAW)
- Flux inside the wire (FCAW-S, FCAW-G)
- A blanket of granular flux (SAW)
2) GMAW (MIG Welding) for Steel
What GMAW is
GMAW uses a continuously fed solid wire electrode and requires a shielding gas to stabilize the arc and protect the weld pool from contamination.
Where GMAW shines in steel work
- Shop fabrication with clean material and controlled wind conditions
- Thin to medium thickness steel where speed and neat beads matter
- Production welding on:
- frames, brackets, sheet/coil components
- general structural attachments
- light-to-medium fabrication assemblies
Strengths
- High productivity (continuous wire feed, minimal starts/stops)
- Clean weld appearance with less slag cleanup than flux-based processes
- Easy to integrate with semi-automation and fixtures for repeatable welds
Limitations
- Wind sensitivity: shielding gas can be blown away outdoors
- Steel surface condition matters (rust/scale/oil increases defects)
- Fit-up and parameter control become critical on heavier sections
Practical buyer/fabricator tips
- Specify whether welding is shop or field (wind/exposure matters)
- If the job is outdoors, consider FCAW-S or wind protection measures
- Ask for the WPS to clearly state the shielding gas and transfer mode for consistent results
3) SMAW (Stick Welding) for Steel Structures & Repairs
What SMAW is
SMAW uses a flux-coated stick electrode. The flux provides shielding and forms slag, while the electrode core provides filler metal.
Where SMAW shines in steel work
- Field welding and repair work (portable, minimal equipment)
- Construction sites where wind and access are challenges
- Maintenance welding on:
- structural members
- heavy equipment
- pipelines and industrial supports (depending on code/process requirements)
Strengths
- Very portable (no wire feeder, no gas cylinder required)
- Works well in windy/outdoor environments
- Good for less-than-perfect site conditions and tight access
Limitations
- Lower deposition/productivity than continuous-wire processes
- Requires frequent electrode changes and more operator skill for long welds
- Slag cleanup is part of the workflow
Consumable selection matters (especially “low-hydrogen”)
Many structural projects emphasize low-hydrogen electrodes and correct handling/storage because moisture control is directly tied to weld quality and cracking risk.
Electrode classification conventions (AWS numbering) are widely used in procurement and WPS documents.
4) FCAW (Flux-Cored Arc Welding) — Self-Shielded vs Gas-Shielded
What FCAW is
FCAW feeds a tubular wire filled with flux ingredients. Depending on the wire type, shielding comes from:
- the flux itself (FCAW-S, self-shielded), or
- flux + external shielding gas (FCAW-G, gas-shielded / “dual-shield”)
FCAW-S (Self-Shielded Flux Core)
Self-shielded flux core does not require external shielding gas, making it popular outdoors and on job sites where wind would disrupt MIG shielding.
Best uses
- Outdoor structural steel erection (when allowed by code/WPS)
- Field fabrication and repair
- Faster alternative to stick welding in many construction scenarios
FCAW-G (Gas-Shielded / Dual-Shield)
Gas-shielded flux core combines wire flux with a shielding gas, often chosen for high deposition and strong mechanical performance in shop environments, including out-of-position welding on thicker sections.
Best uses
- Structural fabrication shops
- Heavy fillets and groove welds on medium-to-thick steel
- High-throughput welding where productivity is critical
Why fabricators choose FCAW
- Higher productivity than stick in many cases (continuous wire feed)
- Often more tolerant of mill scale than pure MIG workflows (still, preparation matters)
- Strong option for out-of-position welding in structural fabrication
5) SAW (Submerged Arc Welding) for Heavy Plate & Long Seams
What SAW is
SAW uses a continuously fed wire (or multiple wires) and forms the arc under a blanket of granular flux. This brings two major benefits: high productivity and a more covered arc environment.
Where SAW dominates steel manufacturing
SAW is a go-to process for:
- Thick plate welding
- Long straight seams
- Automated or mechanized welding in:
- plate girders
- columns and beams with long groove welds
- pressure vessel shells (depending on code/WPS)
- large pipe seams and spiral/longitudinal welding lines (industry-dependent)
Strengths
- Very high deposition rates and excellent productivity in mechanized setups
- Consistent weld quality in repeatable production environments
- Improved operator comfort due to the covered arc characteristics (often described as low open arc exposure)
Limitations
- Typically best suited to flat/rotated positions and long seams
- Requires flux handling, recovery, and slag removal workflow
- Less flexible for short, complex field joints compared with SMAW/FCAW
6) Side-by-Side Comparison (Steel Buyer’s View)
| Process | Common Name | Shielding Method | Best Environment | Typical Steel Use Cases | Key Advantage | Common Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GMAW | MIG | External shielding gas | Indoor/shop | light–medium fabrication, clean material | Clean + fast + easy to fixture | Wind/gas sensitivity outdoors |
| SMAW | Stick | Flux-coated electrode creates shielding + slag | Field/site | repairs, erection, site welding | Portability + wind tolerant | Slower; more stops/starts |
| FCAW-S | Self-shielded flux core | Flux in wire (no gas) | Outdoor/field | structural site welding, heavier sections | Productive outdoors | More slag/fume; wire choice matters |
| FCAW-G | Dual-shield | Flux + shielding gas | Shop / controlled field | structural fabrication, thick/out-of-position | High deposition + strong welds | Gas management; parameter control |
| SAW | Submerged arc | Granular flux blanket | Automated shop | heavy plate, long seams, production welding | Highest productivity in automation | Not ideal for short/complex field joints |
7) How to Choose the Right Process (A Practical Decision Guide)
Choose GMAW (MIG) when:
- You’re welding in a shop with controlled airflow
- Steel is clean/prepped, fit-up is consistent
- You want speed, clean appearance, and repeatability
Choose SMAW (Stick) when:
- You need maximum portability
- Work is outdoors, remote, or tight access
- The job involves repairs, short welds, or varied joint conditions
Choose FCAW when:
- You need higher productivity than stick, especially on structural work
- FCAW-S for outdoor/windy job sites (no gas cylinder dependency)
- FCAW-G for high-throughput shop welding or thick/out-of-position welding
Choose SAW when:
- You have long seams and thick plate
- Mechanization/automation is available
- Productivity and consistent weld quality are top priorities
8) Quality & Compliance Notes for Structural Steel Projects
Many steel construction projects specify welding and inspection requirements using AWS D1.1/D1.1M Structural Welding Code—Steel, which covers welding requirements for welded structures made from commonly used carbon and low-alloy construction steels.
If you are sourcing steel internationally (plate, shapes, fabricated assemblies), align early on:
- Required welding code (AWS D1.1, ASME Section IX context for qualification in many pressure applications, etc.)
- WPS/PQR/WPQ requirements
- NDT requirements (VT/MT/PT/UT/RT) if required by project specs
- Consumable classification and handling expectations (especially for low-hydrogen practices)
9) Safety: Ventilation and Fume Control (Don’t Skip This)
Welding produces fumes and gases that can be hazardous. OSHA standards and guidance emphasize adequate ventilation (general ventilation or local exhaust) to keep fumes within safe limits, plus practical controls like positioning to avoid breathing fume.
For job sites and shops, good safety language to include in internal procedures:
- Use appropriate ventilation/extraction
- Keep head out of the fume plume; stay upwind outdoors
- Clean coatings/paint residues when feasible before welding
10) FAQs
Is MIG welding the same as GMAW?
“MIG” is the common shop term; the technical process name is GMAW, which uses a continuously fed wire and shielding gas.
What’s the main difference between MIG (GMAW) and flux core (FCAW)?
Both feed wire continuously, but FCAW uses flux-cored wire (self-shielded or gas-shielded), while GMAW relies on external shielding gas and solid wire in typical setups.
Which process is best for outdoor structural steel welding?
Often SMAW (stick) or FCAW-S (self-shielded flux core) because wind can disrupt shielding gas used in GMAW.
Which process is most productive for thick plate and long seams?
SAW is widely used for high-productivity welding on long seams and heavy plate, especially in mechanized/automated production.
Do structural steel projects usually require a welding code?
Yes—many specify AWS D1.1/D1.1M for welded steel structures, plus project-specific inspection and qualification requirements.
Share this post
Get Your Next Project Done!
China Steel Supplier & Manufacturer
THE LARGEST METALS MANUFACTURING
GengFei Steel is a professional “Steel Supplier” located in China, we provide supply service of stainless steel, carbon steel, aluminum and other metal materials.
As an industry-leading company, we are committed to providing our customers with the highest quality raw materials backed by first-class customer service and support. Our wide range of supply includes all kinds of stainless steel plate, tube, wire rod and carbon steel plate, tube, bar and so on. Our team of experienced professionals can help you choose the material that best suits your project needs and ensure your order is delivered on time. Our clients range from small businesses to large manufacturers, and we can provide professional service and support no matter the size of your needs.